Welcome to the West Bank, the most disputed land on earth

On my final day working in the West Bank, I made the fateful decision to buy some of Hebron’s famed ceramics. One of my colleagues insisted there was none better in the Middle East and I needed gifts for family and friends. It was a choice I had plenty of time to regret while I was being questioned in a security room at Tel Aviv airport about where I’d been and what I’d done during my stay. Ceramics wrapped in a Palestinian newspaper was a schoolboy error.

Children, West Bank, Palestine
Bedouin settlement of Umm al-Kheir, West Bank, Palestine
Bedouin settlement of Umm al-Kheir, West Bank, Palestine

Hebron is home to the Ibrahimi Mosque, the Cave of the Patriarchs to Israelis, and illustrates many of the intractable problems between the two communities. It’s sacred to Jews and Muslims. After the 1967 Six Day War, Jews were permitted to pray here for the first time in 2,000 years. Since then, it’s been the scene of numerous violent attacks upon Jewish and Muslim worshipers. Most notoriously the 1994 murder of 29 Palestinians by Israeli settler Baruch Goldstein.

The massacre sparked mass protests, more deaths and two suicide bombings carried out by Palestinians in Israel. Tensions in Hebron often run high between the few hundred Israeli settlers living in the Old Town, and the overbearing military presence needed to protect them, and the 215,000-strong Palestinian population who call Hebron home. I had four hours in the security room to contemplate this history as all my possessions were x-rayed.

West Bank, Palestine
West Bank, Palestine
West Bank, Palestine
West Bank, Palestine
West Bank, Palestine

There is a fanatical attachment to religious sites like this across the West Bank, and the grievances built up over many violent incidents make a reconciliation and a Palestinian State less likely. Outside the busy streets of Hebron, a lot of Palestine looked like brown wasteland and bare concrete buildings. There are fertile areas but it’s a hard land in more ways than one. A haze in the distance that looked like air pollution was vapour from the Dead Sea.

Visiting small communities with a mobile medical clinic for mothers and children we found ourselves in larger villages like Yatta and Carmel, but more often than not we’d drive through tiny places that were little more than a scattering of poor looking buildings. The occasional battered car would trundle past, its passengers giving us quizzical looks. Life here often seemed impoverished, and at times like there was no life at all.

This region highlights one of the major conflicts between Palestinians and Israelis: settlements. Areas claimed by Palestinians are effectively under the control of Israel and there is a string of Israeli settlements, considered illegal under international law, running across the hilltops and protected by the Israeli military. You can spot them easily on satellite images. In a uniformly brown landscape, well irrigated areas of bright green are a give away.

It was at the Bedouin settlement of Umm al-Kheir that the absurdity of all this struck me. Here was a community of Bedouin living in near-poverty in makeshift homes, no running water and no electricity, next to the Israeli settlement of Carmel – a place that looks like an American suburb has fallen from the sky into the desert. Identikit homes surrounded by greenery and razor wire. It’s utterly surreal.

Bedouin settlement of Umm al-Kheir, West Bank, Palestine
Bedouin settlement of Umm al-Kheir, West Bank, Palestine
Bedouin settlement of Umm al-Kheir, West Bank, Palestine
Mother and child health clinic, West Bank, Palestine
Mother and child health clinic, West Bank, Palestine

Despite the overwhelming hospitality and the warmth of the people I met, not to mention the never ending meals and snacks that were part of every visit to every Palestinian home, I finished most days feeling profoundly dispirited. It’s almost impossible to see a way out of the deadlock, and things have only gotten worse in the last few years. A fact that I’m reminded of every time I use one of my ceramic bowls.

14 thoughts on “Welcome to the West Bank, the most disputed land on earth

  1. Wrapped in a Palestinian newspaper? What were you thinking?
    Agreed. I remember my father (raised in Egypt) listening to the radio reports of the 6 day war.
    There is no solution is there?
    Stay safe Paul

    1. The probably was a time when a vaguely acceptable solution was possible, but I’m beginning to think that has slipped from our grasp. The options before us today are far less palatable.
      Hope all’s well with you Brian? We’ve been having a domestic holiday in Germany, which after three months of lockdown in Berlin was far more exciting than it should have been. Take care.

      1. It seems to me there was a slim chance when Rabin and Arafat signed. Rabin had said “You can only make peace with your enemy”, (No need with friends right?). But that all went down the drain when Rabin was killed. Arafat (who was no choir boy) was probably poisoned later on…
        Glad you enjoyed a small holiday. Looks like Europe is on the right track. Here, we seem on our way to Hell…
        Be good.

  2. So sorry that the ceramics got you into trouble, or at least searched, but thankful that you are OK. You said it as I see it: brown wasteland. This area seems to have nothing going for it, but you also mentioned the genuine friendliness of the people. They must be quite tolerant and resilient to live here. Thanks for excellent photos and an account that will stick with me.

    1. Thank you. Resilient is the word, indeed. I’d have gotten away with the ceramics but for the newspaper. If I’d given it any thought in advance I’d have replaced it with an Israeli newspaper, or no newspaper, maybe then I wouldn’t have almost missed my flight.

      1. It would be a scary incident for me!

  3. A disgraceful tragedy.

    1. Seventy-five years of political failure and tragedy piled upon tragedy.

  4. Like you I have no idea how they can ever find a way out of this situation. Thank you for another illuminating post though.

    1. I seems like there is a tragic endgame playing out these days, it’s unlikely to end well.

  5. Well articulated! I can totally empathise…and while history may not be the same, it is that same doomed feeling I get when I see/hear about Kashmir & India/Pak. Anyway on a related note, if you havent already read, you may like The Lemon Tree by Sandy Nolan.

    1. Indeed, another intractable problem that only generates more violence. I have a feeling I may have seen the film of The Lemon Tree, about an old lady whose lemon trees are threatened by the arrival of an Israeli general or politician in the house next door? Is that right? I remember it being heartbreaking.

      1. Nah, thats a different story. This is of a palestinian and israeli who inhabit the same house at two different points in time and their unlikely truce.

      2. Its a heartwarming story actually 🙂

Leave a Reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this:
search previous next tag category expand menu location phone mail time cart zoom edit close